On Seneca Street | On The Water | On Elmwood!
MENU
OUR
Cookies & Cream combines the best sourced ice cream and ingredients with freshly baked cookies to create a product that is new, refreshing and unlike any other.
From classic ice cream delights to our Sundae Creations and cookie towers.
​
Check out our full menu below for in-store and online ordering
*Online order is select items
Cookies & Cream
Signature Sundae Creations
$9.75
1. Chocolate Chip Cookie, Vanilla, Hot Fudge, Sprinkles, Whip, Cherry
2. Reese’s PB Cup Cookie, Vanilla, Peanut Butter Sauce, Reese’s, Whip, Cherry
3. Salted Caramel Cookie, Chocolate Lover’s Chocolate, Caramel, Pretzels, Whip, Cherry
4. M&M Cookie, Cookie Dough, Hot Fudge, Rainbow Sprinkles, Whip, Cherry
5. Sugar Cookie, Strawberry, Hot Fudge, Brownies, Sprinkles, Whip, Cherry
6. Lemon Blueberry Cookie, Vanilla, Strawberries, Whip, Cherry
7. Macadamia Nut Cookie, Maine Black Bear, Hot Fudge, Peanuts, Whip, Cherry
8. Snack Aisle Cookie, Butter Pecan, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter Sauce, Pretzels, Whip, Cherry
Soft Serve Custard
Kiddie Regular Large
$3.50 $4.50 $5.50
Vanilla Chocolate Twist
FlavorBurst Available Only at Boatyard
$0.50
Peanut Butter Birthday Cake
Caramel Black Cherry
Blue Goo Coffee ‘n’ Creme
Bubblegum Strawberry (pictured)
77's
Try one of our 19… 77’s (Blizzards)
$6.50
​
Cookies & Cream Snicker’s
Cookie Dough Cereal
Sugar Cookie Heath Bar
Chocolate Turtle Andes Mint
S’mores Reese’s Pieces
Reese’s Butterfinger
Birthday Worms & Dirt
Oreo M&M
Strawberry Cheesecake Brownie
Chocolate Covered Caramel Pretzel
Giant Cookie Sandwich
$9.75
Choose any 2 of our Signature Cookies
and choose any Soft Serve flavor
or
one of our twenty-four flavors of Hard Ice Cream
​
​
Rolled in our signature sprinkle blend
Ice Cream Cakes
6" $35 - serves 6-8 10" $48 - serves 16-18
Choose a flavor based on any of our Signature Cookie flavors.
Standard cakes have 1 layer of chocolate ice cream with a filing based on your cookie flavor
​
All custom cake orders require 72 hour advance notice.
​
We have limited cakes for walk-in purchase daily, call for daily flavor listings.
Cookie Towers
$30
Choose a flavor based on any of our Signature Cookie flavors.
​
Every cookie tower is made with Buttercream Frosting and every layer
is filled with a topping matching your tower flavor.
​
All custom cookie tower orders require 24 hours advance notice.
​
Milkshakes
$5.75
​
Vanilla Strawberry
Chocolate Blackberry
Peanut Butter Orange
Toasted Marshmallow Cookie Butter
$6.75
Traditional Sundaes
Hot Fudge
Caramel
Peanut Butter
Strawberry
Novelties
Artisan Soda $3.25
Artisanal Ice Cream Float $6.75
Bottled Water $2.00
Ice Cream Cake 6” $35.00
Ice Cream Cake 10” $48.00
Cookie Tower $30.00
Add Ons
Homemade Waffle Cone $0.75
Additional Toppings $0.50
